(919) 307-8585 3909 Sunset Ridge Rd Suite 201
Raleigh, North Carolina 27607

Blog

Multiple Capsular Contractures – Is It Time For Implant Removal?

Multiple Capsular Contractures by Dr Glenn Lyle

Breast implants are meant to enhance confidence and restore balance. But sometimes, complications keep returning. Dr. Glenn Lyle, Board-Certified Plastic Surgeon in Raleigh, NC, frequently sees women who are struggling with multiple capsular contractures – a frustrating cycle of tightening scar tissue that distorts the breast, causes discomfort, and drains self-confidence. For many women, the question eventually becomes whether it is time to consider removing their implants entirely. This decision can feel overwhelming, but it can also provide relief, empowerment, and a renewed sense of well-being. 

Capsular contracture is one of the most common reasons women seek revision breast surgery in the United States. It can affect women of all ages and backgrounds, and when it recurs more than once, it often forces patients to evaluate whether continuing with implants is still the right choice for them. Dr. Lyle provides experienced guidance for women facing this crossroad, ensuring that every patient feels heard and supported throughout the process.

Understanding Capsular Contracture

✓ What It Is

When a breast implant is placed, the body naturally forms a capsule of scar tissue around it. In most women, this capsule remains soft, pliable, and protective. It acts like a natural lining that holds the implant in place. However, in some cases, the capsule contracts and tightens excessively. This condition, known as capsular contracture, can range from a subtle firmness to a painful hardening that dramatically alters the appearance of the breasts. It is often graded on the Baker scale, with Grade I representing a normal, soft breast and Grade IV representing severe pain, hardness, and distortion.

✓ Symptoms

Women experiencing capsular contracture often notice a gradual change. The breasts may feel firmer, less natural, or more rigid. Discomfort may increase over time, sometimes becoming persistent or painful enough to interfere with daily life. As the capsule tightens, the implant may appear displaced, often riding too high on the chest, creating an unnatural look. These changes can affect clothing choices, body image, and self-esteem, adding to the emotional weight of the condition.

✓ Why It Happens

The causes of capsular contracture are still not fully understood, but most experts agree that multiple factors contribute. Inflammation, small amounts of blood collecting around the implant, or the presence of microscopic bacteria can all increase the risk of capsule thickening. In some cases, older implants may leak or rupture, which can trigger further scarring. Dr. Glenn Lyle emphasizes that implant choice and placement are key factors in lowering risks. He uses smooth, high-quality implants such as Sientra and Motiva . Recent innovations in implant design have lessened the rate of capsular contracture.

He also often recommends submuscular or subfascial placement, which has been shown to reduce the likelihood of recurrence compared to implants placed directly under the gland.

Why Some Women Face Multiple Capsular Contractures

✗ Recurrence After Surgery

Although a single capsular contracture can often be corrected with a capsulectomy and implant exchange, recurrence is not uncommon. Once a woman has experienced this complication, the likelihood of it happening again is significantly increased. Revision surgery can temporarily correct the issue, but the body may still respond in the same way, leading to further contracture. This recurring cycle can feel discouraging and exhausting.

✗ Risk Factors

Several factors contribute to why some women face repeated contractures while others never develop them. Implant placement above the muscle is a major contributor. Certain implant textures and surfaces have also been linked to higher risks. Some women may be genetically predisposed to developing thicker scar tissue or have a history of excessive scarring elsewhere on the body. Post-surgical complications such as hematomas or infections can also trigger the capsule to harden again. Over time, tissue quality may be compromised by repeated surgeries, making recurrence even more likely.

✗ Emotional Strain

The emotional burden of repeated surgeries should not be underestimated. Patients often feel like they are stuck in a cycle of operations, recovery, and disappointment. Each surgery requires time off from work and family responsibilities, financial investment, and emotional energy. Many women express feeling frustrated, disheartened, and unsure of what to do next. Dr. Lyle believes in choosing surgical strategies that provide long-term stability rather than simply repeating procedures that have already failed. Frequently the different type of implant is chosen and a new location- like under the muscle if it was previously on top. Also he uses a variety of meshes and biological materials which have proven to help prevent the recurrence of capsular contracture. This approach helps patients break free from the exhausting cycle of recurrence.

Treatment Approaches: When Is Implant Removal The Answer?

– Revision Options Before Removal

For some women, there may still be one more opportunity to attempt a revision before considering implant removal. This could involve a capsulectomy, which is the removal of part or all of the scar capsule, combined with implant exchange. Sometimes moving the implant to a new pocket, such as from above the muscle to below, provides more stable results. In addition, the use of biologic mesh or acellular dermal matrix (ADM) can help support the implant pocket and decrease the risk of recurrence. These materials act like an internal scaffold, providing reinforcement to weakened tissues and giving the body a better foundation for healing.

– When Revisions Fail

However, there comes a point when repeated revisions no longer make sense. If a woman has endured multiple capsular contractures despite carefully executed surgeries, or if the discomfort and cosmetic distortion remain severe, implant removal becomes a very reasonable choice. Continuing with additional revisions can weaken breast tissue further, prolong recovery time, and add to emotional fatigue. In these situations, women may find that removal provides the best chance at long-term comfort and satisfaction.

– Implant Removal (Explant Surgery)

Explant surgery involves the removal of the implants along with partial or total removal of the surrounding capsule. The decision between partial or total capsulectomy depends on each patient’s anatomy and surgical history. Dr. Glenn Lyle often combines implant removal with a breast lift to restore a natural, lifted appearance. This helps patients achieve a youthful, proportionate contour even without implants. For many women, this surgery provides a sense of closure and a renewed confidence in their body.

Breast Implant Removal Before and After Photos





Breast Implant Removal Page Breast Implant Removal Gallery

Alternatives To Complete Removal

Mesh & Supportive Techniques

Not every woman who has experienced multiple contractures wants to remove her implants entirely. For these patients, supportive techniques are available. Internal mesh support can provide added stability, reducing stress on breast tissue and helping the implant remain in its proper position. Materials such as Durasorb, Galaflex,Strattice or Ovitex are sometimes used to reinforce the implant pocket and decrease the likelihood of future problems. These supportive methods can extend the life of implants and offer an alternative for women who still prefer to maintain breast volume.

Smaller Implants + Fat Transfer

Another approach is to replace larger implants with smaller ones while supplementing the breasts with fat transfer. Fat is harvested from areas such as the abdomen or thighs, purified, and carefully injected into the breasts. This combination provides natural softness, improved shape, and subtle volume enhancement. By reducing the size of the implants, stress on the tissue is minimized, and the risk of contracture may be lowered. Many patients appreciate the dual benefit of body contouring in addition to enhanced breast shape.

Meet Dr. Glenn Lyle

Board Certified Plastic Surgeon

Dr. Glenn Lyle, a board-certified plastic surgeon, has been proudly serving the Raleigh, NC, community at Lyle Plastic Surgery and Aesthetics Center since 2002. With a deep passion for helping patients reclaim their confidence, Dr. Lyle specializes in transformative breast surgery and body contouring procedures. Whether addressing the effects of weight loss, pregnancy, or aging, his expert care and artistic approach empower individuals to look and feel their best. Dr. Lyle is dedicated to creating beautiful, natural results that reflect each patient’s personal journey and goals.

Meet Dr. Glenn Lyle
Get Started

The Patient Journey: What To Expect If You Choose Removal

Personalized Consultation

Every patient’s journey begins with an in-depth consultation at Dr. Lyle’s Raleigh office. During this visit, Dr. Lyle listens carefully to each woman’s concerns and goals. He reviews medical history, evaluates the breasts, and discusses all surgical options. Using Crisilix 3D planning tools, he can help patients visualize what their results might look like after removal or revision. This level of personalization helps women feel empowered and confident in their decision-making.

The Surgery

Implant removal is performed under safe general or sedation  anesthesia, with constant monitoring throughout the procedure. Dr. Lyle carefully removes the implant and capsule, paying close attention to preserving healthy breast tissue. If a lift is performed at the same time, incisions are strategically placed to achieve the best cosmetic outcome. He adheres to strict sterility protocols, including Betadine preparation, glove changes, and the use of a Keller Funnel when appropriate, to minimize risks and support healing.

Recovery

Recovery from implant removal varies depending on whether a lift or other procedures are performed simultaneously. Drain tubes are sometimes necessary with extensive capsule removal.

 Patients wear supportive garments such  post op bras to assist with healing. Initial swelling and soreness gradually subside within the first few weeks. Most women resume light activity within one to two weeks, with more complete recovery taking place over four to six weeks. Scar care is an important part of recovery, and Dr. Lyle often recommends silicone-based products and scar massage to optimize healing.

Emotional And Lifestyle Benefits Of Choosing Removal

Choosing implant removal after multiple capsular contractures is not just a physical decision – it is an emotional and lifestyle decision as well. Many women experience immediate relief from chronic tightness and discomfort. The fear of recurrence fades, replaced with peace of mind and freedom from repeated surgeries. Women also describe feeling more confident in their natural body, embracing a new sense of self-acceptance. For some, this decision represents taking control of their health and their future. In Raleigh, Dr. Lyle has helped countless women feel empowered by choosing removal, restoring not only their appearance but also their confidence and peace of mind.

Why Choose Dr. Glenn Lyle For Capsular Contracture And Implant Removal?

Experience & Expertise

Dr. Lyle is a board-certified plastic surgeon with decades of experience in breast surgery. His expertise includes complex revisions and explant procedures, making him a trusted choice for women facing challenging surgical decisions. His background in aesthetic breast surgery ensures that even difficult cases are handled with precision and artistry.

Patient-Centered Philosophy

Dr. Lyle’s approach is deeply patient-focused. He believes in open, honest conversations that fully explain the pros and cons of each option. He respects each patient’s unique goals, whether they choose to maintain implants, replace them, or remove them entirely. His goal is always to achieve natural, balanced results that look and feel right for each woman.

Advanced Surgical Techniques

Dr. Lyle uses advanced surgical methods and the highest-quality implants available. His commitment to sterility and patient safety is unwavering. When appropriate, he incorporates supportive mesh or fat transfer techniques to improve outcomes and durability. His careful planning and surgical skill help women achieve results that are not only aesthetically pleasing but also long-lasting.

FAQs About Multiple Capsular Contractures

Repeated contracture can signal that your body is prone to this reaction and may require a different strategy. For many women, this is when implant removal becomes the most logical and sustainable choice.

Yes, it is possible for both breasts to develop capsular contracture, though often one breast is affected more severely. Each side may require a different surgical plan depending on severity.

Implant removal with capsulectomy is the most definitive way to eliminate the problem. While revision strategies may help, removal ensures that the cycle of contracture does not continue.

Dr. Lyle often recommends combining removal with a breast lift to reshape and elevate the breast tissue. This helps avoid a deflated look and restores natural proportions. Sometimes fat grafting is incorporated.

Mesh and ADM provide additional support, but they cannot guarantee zero recurrence. They do, however, significantly lower the risk in selected patients who wish to keep implants.

Recovery from removal is often similar or sometimes easier than revision with new implants, especially when paired with a lift. Patients usually find relief from discomfort and enjoy a smoother healing process.

Many patients feel a profound sense of relief and empowerment. While some initially fear losing volume, most report renewed confidence and comfort, with peace of mind knowing the cycle of recurrence has ended.

Repeated contracture can signal that your body is prone to this reaction and may require a different strategy. For many women, this is when implant removal becomes the most logical and sustainable choice.

Yes, it is possible for both breasts to develop capsular contracture, though often one breast is affected more severely. Each side may require a different surgical plan depending on severity.

Implant removal with capsulectomy is the most definitive way to eliminate the problem. While revision strategies may help, removal ensures that the cycle of contracture does not continue.

Dr. Lyle often recommends combining removal with a breast lift to reshape and elevate the breast tissue. This helps avoid a deflated look and restores natural proportions. Sometimes fat grafting is incorporated.

Mesh and ADM provide additional support, but they cannot guarantee zero recurrence. They do, however, significantly lower the risk in selected patients who wish to keep implants.

Recovery from removal is often similar or sometimes easier than revision with new implants, especially when paired with a lift. Patients usually find relief from discomfort and enjoy a smoother healing process.

Many patients feel a profound sense of relief and empowerment. While some initially fear losing volume, most report renewed confidence and comfort, with peace of mind knowing the cycle of recurrence has ended.

Take The Next Step

If you have struggled with multiple capsular contractures, you don’t need to live in discomfort or uncertainty. Dr. Glenn Lyle, Board-Certified Plastic Surgeon in Raleigh, NC, can guide you toward the safest and most natural solution for your unique needs. His combination of surgical expertise, patient-centered care, and advanced techniques provides reassurance that you are in experienced hands.

Take control of your comfort, confidence, and future today. Schedule a private consultation with Dr. Glenn Lyle to explore your options. His Raleigh practice is here to support you every step of the way.

Visit the website to learn more and request your consultation.

 Call 919-307-8585 to schedule an appointment.

Further Reading

Let’s Start a Conversation